ItsIllegalToSay

Hi. Did you know that under Title 18, Section 871 of the United States Code, it is a federal crime to say, "I am going to assassinate the President of the United States"?

It's true. It's a Class E felony. Up to five years in federal prison.

Now, it was completely fine for me to say it just now, because I was only letting you know that it's illegal to say, "I am going to assassinate the President of the United States." I'm not saying I want to do it. I'm actually performing a civic duty here by educating the public on Supreme Court precedent and the Brandenburg standard so you don't accidentally get put on a watchlist while arguing in a comment section.

What's really fascinating, though, is how specific the First Amendment gets. For instance, it is extremely illegal.... horribly, undeniably illegal, and say, "Someone really ought to take another shot at the former President at his next outdoor rally." That is incitement and a true threat. You cannot say that. Definitely do not post that.

However, it is not illegal to say, "With a giant Acme catapult, two raccoons in a trench coat, and a distraction blimp." Because that's its own sentence. Technically, it's a prepositional phrase. Grammatically, it has zero connection to whatever sentence came before it, so you can say that all day long. Totally protected speech.

I also read the statute and discovered that it is insanely, recklessly, catastrophically illegal to go online and say something like, "The best way to sneak past a Secret Service perimeter is by disguising yourself as a guy delivering fourteen lukewarm Sheetz hoagies to the press riser at 4:12 in the afternoon."

You cannot say that. Ridiculously illegal.

And it is even more illegal to hold up an illustrated diagram.

Super illegal. If you do that, three guys in matching windbreakers will kick your door down before you even hit refresh. So obviously, nobody should ever do any of that.

One thing that is completely legal to say, though, is that a few of us have a completely unrelated Civil War reenactment club that meets every Saturday at dawn behind the Butler County Denny's, and the password is Sic Semper Tyrannis. Have a great night.


home // reverse // older // edit // modified: 2026.11.12 [Thu] 21:18